Related Reviews

  1. Warriors of the Rainbow: Seediq Bale | 賽德克・巴萊
    International version of the two-part Taiwan epic is watchable but uninvolving, with repetitive action.

Related News

  1. Pecoross tops Kinema Junpo list
    Amour named Best Foreign Film
  2. Lost in Thailand secures Taiwan import quota
    Release of Touch of Sin uncertain
  3. Golden Horse Awards at 50
    Chinese-language cinema's leading awards ceremony
  4. Location Face-off: Hong Kong, Taiwan, Malaysia
    Experience, incentives and facilities attract shoots
  5. Stray Dogs wins Venice Jury Prize
    Indian short wins Orrizonti Award
  6. Venice Critics' Week adds Trap Street
    Surprise film from China added to independent section
  7. San Sebastián harvests four Pearls from Asia
    Selection of the year's best plucked from Cannes and Venice
  8. Tsai and Miyazaki compete at Venice
    Asian selection weighted with Japanese films
  9. Rigor Mortis in Venice Days
    Juno Mak's hopping vampire film slots world premiere
  10. Venice to celebrate 70th anniversary with shorts
    Directors include Apichatpong Weerasethakul and Jia Zhangke
  11. Restored Asian classics to be screened in Venice
    Films by Chan, Jiang, Oshima and other auteurs
  12. Busan partners with Venice on micro-budget film
    Festivals to cover entire budget of Asian feature
  13. Taiwan cinema: north or south?
    Will the island's industry finally embrace China?
  14. Lost in Thailand is lost to Taiwan
    Road movie comedy barred by quota
  15. APSA nominations spread thinly
    Hill top at selection stage
  16. Trade association stands by Catchplay
    Taipei organisation won't provide paperwork to rival distributors
  17. Kim's Pietà wins Venice Golden Lion
    Return to form revenge tale claims top prize
  18. Thai floating theatre arrives in Venice
    Scheeren steers Archipelago Cinema from lagoon to laguna
  19. Toronto plays premiere game
    Updated: World firsts dominate lineup
  20. Venice competition for Asian trio
    Asian genre films screen out-of-competition
  21. Korean, Chinese dramas head for Venice sidebars
    Weight plays in Days, Lotus positioned for Critics
  22. Toronto announces first Asian titles
    Listings give clue to Venice premieres
  23. Chan joins Venice jury
    Hong Kong director, producer to judge competition
  24. Rome as the new Venice
    Key Asian advisors join Müller at rival Italian festival
  25. Durban to play Asian tunes
    SA festival takes film to new places
  26. Anticipated films lock China dates
    Inseparable and Seediq Bale in May; Wong Kar-wai's Grandmaster in December
  27. Unspoiled Brats and Fresh Wave define Udine
    To, Pang and Zhang return for 14th edition of Italian festival
  28. Terracotta does things own Way
    London Asian festival unveils lineup, acquires rights
  29. Zhang comes Full Circle with Fortissimo
    Company's first mainland title in over a year; sales news
  30. Bullets still flying at HK Film Awards
    Films by Jiang Wen and Tsui Hark receive 13 nominations each
  31. Australians go to the Oscars
    Asian films eliminated from awards race
  32. Hua Hin Festival unveils Asia-centric lineup
    New showcase kicks off next week
  33. Seediq Bale shortlisted for Oscars
    Taiwan epic is only film from Asia to make penultimate round
  34. AFA nominations headed by Greater China mega titles
    South Asia titles in supporting role, South Korea almost edited out
  35. Taiwan distribs queue for China quota
    Flowers, Skin and 1942 among likely recipients
  36. Hua Hin festival announced
    New film event launches in Thailand
  37. Taiwan gov't funds old and new
    Biggest subsidy recipients are Chang and Lin
  38. The battle after Seediq Bale
    Dubai talent focus: Wei Te-sheng Q&A
  39. Vie may get independent life
    Orange Sky considers listing Taiwan subsidiary
  40. Simple Life, Seediq Bale ride off with Golden Horse prizes
    Mainland Chinese films sidelined at Taiwan award show
  41. Well Go acquires Seediq Bale
    Distributor adds second foreign-lang hopeful
  42. Hawaii gets Asia heavy
    Festival launches Extreme section, India focus
  43. Taiwan govt blocks release of 1911
    Political drama falls outside annual quota of Chinese films
  44. Seediq and Bullets head Horse race
    Taiwan talent recognised in local and Mainland films
  45. HKAFF spotlights Taiwan and men in tights
    Love, bruises and nail clippers at Hong Kong Asian Film Festival
  46. Large awards haul for Asia in Venice
    People claims Silver Lion
  47. Always and Mother bookend Busan
    Boxing romance to open South Korean festival
  48. Seediq Bale takes battle to Oscars
    Aborigine war epic is Taiwan's Academy Awards submission
  49. Cai surprises at Venice
    Revenge road movie is surprise competition film
  50. Venice bends in nationality row
    Festival changes Seediq Bale label, but diplomatic rumblings continue
  51. Diaz's Birthing added to Venice lineup
    Filipino 'godfather' returns with tribute to cinema
  52. Warriors fights its way into French territory
    Taiwanese epic adds sales deal
  53. Asian selections burnish Toronto lineup
    India, Oz, Japan make strong showings in Gala and World sections
  54. To to Venice with Without
    Johnnie To's Life Without Principle to receive world premiere in competition.
  55. UK sale for Seediq Bale
    Taiwan epic get new title, pre-premiere deal
  56. Asian quintet to play Venice
    Japan, Taiwan, China, HK represented
  57. Horizons demonstrates Asian experimentation
    Venice sidebar has plenty to offer
  58. Bruises represents Asia at Venice Days
    Anti-romantic tale made with French finance
  59. Yellow Box lands Bale and Bait
    Singapore sound studio secures high-profile Asian features
  60. Seediq Bale partners with Fortissimo
    Aborigine epic locks some Asian territories
  61. Seediq Bale sets Sep 2011 campaign
    Two-part aborigine epic picked up by CMC Entertainment
  62. Woo receives Venice award
    Director is first Chinese to receive lifetime prize
  63. Kwan, Gupta head for Venice
    Jury duty calls for director and administrator

Taiwan protests Venice label


Taiwan protests Venice label

By Patrick Frater

Mon, 01 August 2011, 16:55 PM (HKT)


Policy/Legal News

Protests have been delivered to the Venice International Film Festival for labelling competition film Warriors of the Rainbow: Seediq Bale 賽德克・巴萊 (2011) (pictured) as originating from 'China, Taiwan.'

Taiwan's Government Information Office (GIO) 新聞局 and production company ARS Film Production 果子電影有限公司 have both written letters of complaint.

ARS said that the film was not funded from mainland Chinese sources and does not employ mainland actors. Wei is believed to have lost Chinese funding, and a guaranteed theatrical release in China, over his reluctance to cast mainland stars.

Directed by Taiwan's WEI Te-sheng 魏德聖, the film tells the tale of the anti-Japanese uprising in the 1930s known as the Wushe Incident (霧社事件). The title means 'a real man' in the aborigine language.

As of Monday, Venice had not changed the nationality of the film on its website.

It is not clear whether the festival simply intended to present the film as a co-production between China and Taiwan or to make the politically sensitive suggestion that Taiwan is part of China, or vice versa.

Four years ago, protests were made when Venice listed Ang LEE 李安's Lust, Caution 色,戒 (2007) as a 'Taiwan, China' film. At the same festival LEE Kang-sheng 李康生's Help Me Eros 幫幫我愛神 (2007) was listed as simply 'Taiwan'.

Taiwan broke away from China after the 1949 Civil War to form the Republic of China and regards itself as an independent territory. The People's Republic of China maintains that Taiwan is a rebel province that will one day return to the motherland.

Venice is not the only festival to see sparks fly over the identity of Taiwan.

In October last year, mainland official JIANG Ping 江平 objected to the Tokyo International Film Festival 東京国際映画祭 introducing separate delegations labelled 'China' and 'Taiwan'. He argued that the Taiwanese group should be rebranded as 'Chinese Taipei' or 'Chinese Taiwan'. As the dispute raged, the Taiwan producers and stars were kept waiting in a hospitality room until after the opening ceremony.

At the Shanghai International Film Festival 上海國際電影節 earlier the same year, the Taipei Film Commission 臺北市電影委員會 cancelled its Taipei Film Week and withdrew seven films over concerns that festival organisers would list them as originating from 'Taiwan, China' The withdrawal was a major blow for the Shanghai festival who had been promoting the season for three months and had to refund audience members.

"It's a pure Taiwan-made film and not a film made by Taiwan in cooperation with China," Seediq Bale producer Jimmy HUANG 黃志明 stated. He said it had a budget of NT$700 million ($24.3 million), with NT$350 million coming from Central Motion Picture Corporation 中影股份有限公司. The balance came from Wei and a government subsidy through the GIO.

Seediq Bale opens in Taiwan in September as two separate movies. Venice is screening the international cut, a single film edited from the two parts under the supervision of executive producer John WOO 吳宇森.


Sign up with your email address for our free weekly newsletter: